Dare To Ask Talk And News About Our Differences By PHILLIP MILANO
Question
If someone is upset with you and waving their hand with fingers outstretched in the air a few inches from your face, is it considered racist to say “You need to stop going all Shanaynay on me”?
Kay, white, Jacksonville
Replies
That would be racist regardless of what the other person was doing. Obviously the use of the name Shanaynay refers to the sometimes creative names of African-Americans. If you said “Star Jones” instead of “Shanaynay,” it might be different because Star is a particular person known for certain things and you could mean “You need to stop buying all those Payless shoes.”
F., white female, California
That’s been out of style since the show Martin, which featured the character “Shenaenae.”
Lynne H., Louisville, Ky.
If I was doing that to someone, and then they said something like that, I’d probably burst out laughing. That being said, I probably would never say that unless I was joking around with my friends.
Cassy, 22, white, Jacksonville
Would this even be an issue if I was mimicking, say, an Italian gesture and saying “Don’t get all Mario on me?” As an outsider to America, I think black people seem to be hypersensitive about the color of their skin. In Australia I think we understand that . . . there are generalizations that are true to certain cultures and/or races, and it’s fine to poke fun at people as long as it’s done in a non-aggressive way.
Jason G., Australian, Germany
Expert says
Du-uh, it’s Sheneneh, not Shanaynay or Shenaenae. (OK, we confess we hadn’t heard of her, either.)
“She” was actually a he, a “ghetto girl” portrayed by Martin Lawrence on the Fox sitcom Martin in the mid-’90s. Sheneneh Jenkins was a sassy, stereotypically over-the-top character who shouted phrases like “Oh no you di-in’t!”
So here’s the key, said John R. Rickford, professor of linguistics at Stanford University and author of Spoken Soul: The Story of Black English: Is the phrase in question being used in a general way to try to paint African- Americans with a broad brush, or is it referring to the specific character on Martin?
If the latter, that absorbs a bit of the sting on the offensiveness scale, he said. But let’s say the person had thrown out a “creative-sounding” name not tied to a TV character (may we humbly suggest “LaShaquanda”). “In that case, she might be disparaging an aspect of black cultural behavior in general,” Rickford said. “If she’s talking to a black person and says that, it would be interpreted as a put-down.”
He stressed there were no “hard-and-fast” rules, because context is so important – though there is still “a lot of sensitivity of boundaries between black and white styles.”
“It’s not like a committee sits down and says this is OK and this isn’t … it’s hard to draw a line.”