Dare To Ask Talk And News About Our Differences By PHILLIP J. MILANO
Remember the kids in school who hurled insults whenever they saw someone they deemed too fat, too dorky, the wrong skin color, a sissy, the wrong faith, a foreigner?
The truly deft members of this abuse posse almost never seemed to get caught in the act, much less in trouble.
Then there was everybody else. The kids who wound up getting smacked on the head by Mom just for asking an innocent (read: witheringly frank) question about somebody “different.” Of course, that somebody was usually within easy earshot at the grocery store, but let’s not quibble.
Assuming you were part of the latter group, I have a proposal. If you’re still willing to ask those kinds of earnest questions, I’ll try to get them answered for you. With no smack on the head or kick in the pants for your efforts.
This column’s premise is that people are dying to know more about people of other races, cultures, religions, sexual orientations, ages, genders and classes.
They’ve just forgotten it’s OK to seek the information.
Somewhere along the way, after all the admonishments from our parents, teachers, ministers or whomever, we lost a bit of the natural curiosity of our childhoods. Blissful ignorance and artful separation became worthy substitutes in a world gone politically, maddeningly, correct.
Several years ago I asked an African-American co-worker why urban talk show hosts often seemed to sound almost “too black.” She laughed and asked if I thought Jay Leno sounded “too white.” I didn’t feel embarrassed, but I got her point. Playing off a hunch that more people would like to have such candid exchanges, I started Y? The National Forum on People’s Differences, a Web site that lets people ask each other honest questions about their racial and cultural differences.
Ten million visitors later, Y? has taken on its own life. It’s been featured in media worldwide, and I get asked to speak about it to companies and groups I never thought would be interested. I even coaxed Perigee to publish a book last September based on Y?, titled I Can’t Believe You Asked That!
But now my real dream has come true: to have this conversation appear in my newspaper, for all to see. I’m not talking about dissecting the big issues of the day in this column, but the so-called “smaller” topics that often keep us from getting closer to each other.
Why do we talk the way we do? Eat the way we do? Dress the way we do? Even smell the way we do? Frankly, if we can’t talk about these “superficial” things, well, how are we going to tackle the bigger issues?
So let’s get started. I realize it’s not easy opening up like this, so we’ll use your initials or first name if you’d like. Just send in your questions and replies, and I’ll mix them in with postings from across the country and globe. I’ll even get experts to address your queries.
Take a chance: Become part of a provocative, but necessary, undertaking. Because when we become too safe for our own good, we risk living in an unsafe world.
Question
Why do black men look good in purple suits, but white men look like dorks?
P. Ryan, Harrow, Canada
Replies
Someone will probably try and give some response about coloring of the skin being complementary or not, so let me try and stop such nonsense before it starts. Most men look good in suits. It may be that you have had more instance to notice a black man in a purple suit because some black men wear colored suits to stand out in a crowd. Being originally from Louisiana, where purple is one of the official state colors, I’ve had a chance to see several men of both races in purple suits. The better-looking the man, the better-looking the suit.
Amanda, 21, black female, Boston
Let’s be honest. No one looks good in a purple suit.
Matt, 26, Hispanic male, Houston
I don’t think it’s nonsense to state that skin coloring plays a role in what colors look good. A white woman and a black woman are not always able to wear the same color lipstick and look good in that shade. Therefore, it stands to reason that skin tone makes a difference. Darker skin can carry a brighter (for instance, orange) or deeper color (like purple) better without being overwhelmed by it. Perhaps that’s why the colorful Kente cloth patterns were invented by Africans.
Cassandra, 36, black female, Chicago
Expert says
Constance White, style director for eBay.com and former style writer for The New York Times, says it’s not foolish to think a black man might look better in a purple suit than a white man, for two reasons: color contrast and cultural context.
“Scientifically, we know that black against white is the most graphic you can get, so by the same token the same sort of rules apply to, say, a purple against a brown,” said White. “Perhaps to our natural eye it’s easier on the eye — darker skin tones balance out a brighter color.”
Perhaps as important, “In our community, it’s just a lot more acceptable for a black man to wear a purple suit — even if some of us might be rolling our eyes, it’s still not as shocking as if a white man shows up in a purple suit to a bar mitzvah or church on Sunday or a WASP party.”
Tracing that acceptance inevitably leads one on a path back to Africa, where cultural mores and traditions called for the elite leaders to wear bright colors, White said. The contrast with European society was like night and day, with highprofile leaders there wearing conservative, darker colors.
“There is more of a tradition for individual expression in the black community than in the white community, which comes partly from whites’ religious traditions. In Puritanism and the Church of England, they were very buttoned-up. Not only was it not polite in society to express yourself, it was downright ungodly. Whereas in traditional African religions, the opposite is true,” White noted.
And, just as clothes make the man, the man makes the clothes.
“A black man sort of has a swagger that goes with a purple suit, whereas white men don’t,” White quipped.